TIERED CLASSIFICATION AND REGULATION OF CROSS-BORDER PERSONAL HEALTH DATA FLOWS: THE “NATIONAL SECURITY THRESHOLD” AS A REGULATORY BOUNDARY

Authors

  • ZhaoXia Deng (Corresponding Author) Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, Guangzhou 510515, Guangdong, China.

Keywords:

Personal health data, Cross-border flow, Tiered classification, National security threshold

Abstract

Cross-border flow of personal health data has become a structural requirement in cross-border telemedicine, international multicenter clinical trials, and international collaborative research on genetic data. However, once genetic data, population health maps, and other data are maliciously utilized, they may endanger biological and national security, and the legitimacy of regulation is beyond doubt. The question is not whether to regulate, but what standards to regulate. The current regulations in China place personal health data under both the concepts of “important data” and “sensitive personal information”, but both have threshold ambiguity in the field of health: the important data directory is missing, and the rules for sensitive personal information replace “national security relevance” with “sensitivity”, resulting in a lack of corresponding relationship between review intensity and national security risks. There is a lack of systematic analysis on the triggering conditions for national security review in the context of personal health data, with existing research focusing on institutional comparisons outside the domain or macro construction of general cross-border data flows. This article uses the “national security threshold” as an analytical tool, defining it as a critical set of conditions for data type threshold and flow scenario threshold. It advocates for the typification and reconstruction of health data within the current three-level framework of “core data important data general data”, with national security relevance as the priority axis: core types (human genetic resource information, major infectious disease pathogen genome data, population health vulnerability map) enter the scope of national security review, important types (identifiable personal diagnosis and treatment data) use security assessment as the core process, and general types (de identified statistical data and health management data) apply the facilitation path. On this basis, scenario calibration is carried out with “purpose receiver purpose” as the variable, and the functional differentiation of safety assessment, standard contracts, and national security review is divided into procedural guarantees, supported by regional testing, technical governance, and international scenario integration. The clarification of thresholds is not a weakening of the security bottom line, but a prerequisite for the legitimacy and effectiveness of national security reviews and the predictable compliance path for international cooperation in digital healthcare.

References

[1] National Computer Network Emergency Response Technical Team/Coordination Center of China (CNCERT/CC). 2020 China Internet Network Security Report, 2021.

[2] Ao Q, Pan Y. The EU Experience in the Cross-Border Flow of Personal Health and Medical Data and Its Implications. Medicine and Philosophy, 2025, 46(23): 19-24.

[3] Chen Y Y, Meng Y C. Research on the Legal Regulation of the Cross-Border Flow of Health and Medical Data in Australia and Its Implications for China. Chinese General Practice, 2024, 27(25): 3091.

[4] Jiao Y, Ji J H. Practical Review and Multidimensional Construction of Norms for Cross-Border Data Flow. Journal of Xi’an University of Finance and Economics, 2026, 1: 68.

[5] Lu Y, Yang X Y. Current Regulatory Status and Solutions to the Dilemmas of Cross-Border Flow of Health and Medical Data in China. Medicine and Jurisprudence, 2025.

[6] Bao Y M, Xue Y B. Current Status and Prospects of Life and Health Big Data. Bulletin of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2018, 33(8): 861-865.

[7] Wang G. Towards equitable governance of human genomic data sharing: guided by genomic contextualism. Data & Policy, 2025, 7: e83.

[8] Yang J M, Fang Y, Kuang Y L, et al. Legal Risks and Regulatory Pathways in the Application of Health and Medical Big Data. Journal of Sichuan University (Medical Science Edition), 2026, 57(3): 880-886.

[9] Hong Y Q. Data Classification and Graded Protection from the Perspective of National Security. China Law Review, 2021, 5: 71-78.

[10] National Technical Committee 260 on Cybersecurity of SAC (TC260). Data Security Technology—Rules for Data Classification and Grading. GB/T 43697-2024, 2024.

[11] Xu Z Y, Wang Q. The Full Picture of Compliance Pathways for Outbound Pharmaceutical Data: Scenario Identification and Practical Responses from Clinical Trials to Pharmacovigilance. Zhonglun Wende, 2026. https://www.zhonglunwende.com/index.php/zhuanyewenzhang/3731.html.

[12] Deng X H, Ye J Q, Liang M B, et al. Research on the Dilemmas and Countermeasures in the Elementalization of Health and Medical Data. Chinese Journal of Digital Medicine, 2025, 20(6): 24-29.

[13] Zhao F. On the Legal Guarantees for the Construction of a Trusted Health Data Space in China. Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China (Social Sciences Edition), 2025, 27(6): 112-121.

[14] Duan Z C, Wang Y T, Xu L, et al. A Thousand Mountains Layered like Zhang, a Hundred Rivers Flowing to the Sea: An Interpretation of the Negative List for Outbound Data Transfer in the Beijing Pilot Free Trade Zone (Part II). Hankun Law Offices, 2024. https://www.hankunlaw.com/portal/article/index/cid/8/id/14576.html.

[15] Chen Y M, Ji Z T. The Twin Drivers in Constructing Discursive Power in EU Digital Trade Rules: The Resonance between Unilateral “Adequacy Decisions” and Bilateral Trade Agreements. German Studies, 2025, 6: 92-95.

[16] Regulation (EU) 2025/327 on the European Health Data Space, 2025, arts 57, 68.

[17] Bentzen H B, Castro R, Fears R, et al. Remove Obstacles to Sharing Health Data with Researchers Outside of the European Union. Nature Medicine, 2021, 27(8): 1329-1333.

[18] US Department of Health and Human Services. Guidance Regarding Methods for De-identification of Protected Health Information in Accordance with the HIPAA Privacy Rule. HHS, 2012. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/special-topics/de-identification/index.html.

[19] Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC). Cross-Border Privacy Rules System. APEC, 2011. https://cbprs.org/.

[20] Tovino S A. Not So Private. Duke Law Journal, 2022, 71: 985.

[21] Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC). Chapter 8: Australian Privacy Principle 8 — Cross-Border Disclosure of Personal Information. Version 1.3. Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC), 2025.

[22] The Register. Microsoft to Aussie gov: Privacy rules stifle e-Health. The Register, 2011. https://www.theregister.com/offbeat/2011/11/25/microsoft-to-aussie-gov-privacy-rules-stifle-e-health/743749.

[23] Privacy Commissioner v Telstra Corporation Limited [2017] FCAFC 4. 2017, 249 FCR 24

[24] National Health Commission, Ministry of Public Security, Cyberspace Administration of China, et al. Measures for the Administration of Data Security and Personal Information Protection in Medical and Health Institutions (Trial). Guo Wei Gui Hua Fa [2026] No 6, 2026.

[25] Sun Q Y, Liu Y, Huang J, et al. Management Discussion of Laws and Regulations on Human Genetic Resources in China: A Scoping Review. BMC Medical Ethics, 2026, 27: 114.

[26] Luo Q W. Data Cross-Border Flow Facilitation Reform Upgrades from “Pilot Exploration” to “City-Wide Governance”: Negative List Measures for Outbound Data Benefit Enterprises across the Municipality. Beijing Daily, 2026. https://www.beijing.gov.cn/ywdt/gzdt/202605/t20260512_4646632.html.

[27] Cyberspace Administration of China, Innovation, Technology and Industry Bureau of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government. Implementation Guidelines for the Standard Contract for Cross-Border Flow of Personal Information in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (Mainland, Hong Kong Region). 2023.

[28] Plug R B F. Secure Distributed Machine Learning in Healthcare: A Study on FAIR, Compliance and Cybersecurity for Federated Learning. Thesis, Leiden University, 2025. https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4285632.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-20

Issue

Section

Research Article

DOI:

How to Cite

ZhaoXia Deng. Tiered Classification And Regulation Of Cross-Border Personal Health Data Flows: The “National Security Threshold” As A Regulatory Boundary. AI and Data Science Journal. 2026, 3(2): 37-45. DOI: https://doi.org/10.61784/adsj3042.